How we know Jesus was from Nazareth

Bethlehem is in the Palestinian West Bank, which has been under
Israeli occupation since 1967. It is encircled by a wall erected

Israel in 2002. All entrances and exits are controlled by armed
Israeli soldiers. Israeli forces regularly invade the area,

beating

and abducting residents. Israeli forces sometimes kill them,

including

prominent Palestinian-American journalist Shireen Abu-Akleh,

from a

Christian family from Bethlehem. Due to the influence of the

Israel

lobby, U.S. taxpayers give Israel over $10 million per day. The
churches shown at the end of the video are the Church of the

Nativity

and Christmas Lutheran Church in Bethlehem. Runtime: 1:53 mins.

Bethlehem is controlled by the Palestinians.

Bullshit is just part of Young's nature.

LOL. As it was for Matthew and Luke. They made asses of themselves
(and contradicted each other) with their idiotic contortions to have
Jesus born there.

You must not have read those books yourself, there is NO contradictions.

Post by Ted
(Which, btw, they wouldn't need to have done if it hadn't been common
knowledge that he was from Nazareth. If they were making him up, they
just would've said he was from Bethlehem.)

Ted

2022-12-28 18:45:09 UTC

Bethlehem is in the Palestinian West Bank, which has been under
Israeli occupation since 1967. It is encircled by a wall erected

Israel in 2002. All entrances and exits are controlled by armed
Israeli soldiers. Israeli forces regularly invade the area,

beating

and abducting residents. Israeli forces sometimes kill them,

including

prominent Palestinian-American journalist Shireen Abu-Akleh,

from a

Christian family from Bethlehem. Due to the influence of the

Israel

lobby, U.S. taxpayers give Israel over $10 million per day. The
churches shown at the end of the video are the Church of the

Nativity

and Christmas Lutheran Church in Bethlehem. Runtime: 1:53 mins.

Bethlehem is controlled by the Palestinians.

Bullshit is just part of Young's nature.

LOL. As it was for Matthew and Luke. They made asses of themselves
(and contradicted each other) with their idiotic contortions to have
Jesus born there.

You must not have read those books
yourself, there is NO contradictions.

I'm quite familiar with them, Robert, and there are multiple
contradictions. Shall I list them one at a time?

Dr. Who

2022-12-28 19:47:27 UTC

On Tuesday, December 27, 2022 at 4:26:41 PM UTC-6, P+Barker

Bethlehem is in the Palestinian West Bank, which has been

under

Israeli occupation since 1967. It is encircled by a wall

erected

Post by Ted
by

Israel in 2002. All entrances and exits are controlled by

armed

Israeli soldiers. Israeli forces regularly invade the area,

beating

and abducting residents. Israeli forces sometimes kill them,

including

prominent Palestinian-American journalist Shireen Abu-Akleh,

from a

Christian family from Bethlehem. Due to the influence of the

Israel

lobby, U.S. taxpayers give Israel over $10 million per day.

The

churches shown at the end of the video are the Church of the

Nativity

and Christmas Lutheran Church in Bethlehem. Runtime: 1:53

mins.

Bethlehem is controlled by the Palestinians.

Bullshit is just part of Young's nature.

LOL. As it was for Matthew and Luke. They made asses of themselves
(and contradicted each other) with their idiotic contortions to

have

Post by Ted
Jesus born there.

You must not have read those books
yourself, there is NO contradictions.

I'm quite familiar with them, Robert, and there are multiple
contradictions. Shall I list them one at a time?

In lists of ten would be fine. Thanks

Ted

2022-12-28 21:02:45 UTC

On Wed, 28 Dec 2022 06:50:56 -0800 (PST),

On Tuesday, December 27, 2022 at 4:26:41 PM UTC-6, P+Barker

On Tue, 27 Dec 2022 16:03:37 -0500,

Bethlehem is in the Palestinian West Bank, which has been

under

Israeli occupation since 1967. It is encircled by a wall

erected

Israel in 2002. All entrances and exits are controlled by

armed

Israeli soldiers. Israeli forces regularly invade the area,

beating

and abducting residents. Israeli forces sometimes kill them,

including

prominent Palestinian-American journalist Shireen

Abu-Akleh,

from a

Christian family from Bethlehem. Due to the influence of the

Israel

lobby, U.S. taxpayers give Israel over $10 million per day.

The

churches shown at the end of the video are the Church of the

Nativity

and Christmas Lutheran Church in Bethlehem. Runtime: 1:53

mins.

Bethlehem is controlled by the Palestinians.

Bullshit is just part of Young's nature.

LOL. As it was for Matthew and Luke. They made asses of

themselves

(and contradicted each other) with their idiotic contortions to

have

Jesus born there.

You must not have read those books
yourself, there is NO contradictions.

I'm quite familiar with them, Robert, and there are multiple
contradictions. Shall I list them one at a time?

In lists of ten would be fine. Thanks

I doubt there are ten.

Okay, first one: where did Mary and Joseph live before Jesus was
born? Matthew says Bethlehem, Luke says Nazareth.

Dr. Who

2022-12-28 23:26:56 UTC

On Wed, 28 Dec 2022 06:50:56 -0800 (PST),

On Tuesday, December 27, 2022 at 4:26:41 PM UTC-6, P+Barker

On Tue, 27 Dec 2022 16:03:37 -0500,

Bethlehem is in the Palestinian West Bank, which has

been

under

Israeli occupation since 1967. It is encircled by a wall

erected

Israel in 2002. All entrances and exits are controlled

armed

Israeli soldiers. Israeli forces regularly invade the

area,

beating

and abducting residents. Israeli forces sometimes kill

them,

including

prominent Palestinian-American journalist Shireen

Abu-Akleh,

from a

Christian family from Bethlehem. Due to the influence

of the

Israel

lobby, U.S. taxpayers give Israel over $10 million per

day.

The

churches shown at the end of the video are the Church

of the

Nativity

1:53

mins.

Bethlehem is controlled by the Palestinians.

Bullshit is just part of Young's nature.

LOL. As it was for Matthew and Luke. They made asses of

themselves

(and contradicted each other) with their idiotic contortions

have

Jesus born there.

You must not have read those books
yourself, there is NO contradictions.

I'm quite familiar with them, Robert, and there are multiple
contradictions. Shall I list them one at a time?

In lists of ten would be fine. Thanks

I doubt there are ten.
Okay, first one: where did Mary and Joseph live before Jesus was
born? Matthew says Bethlehem, Luke says Nazareth.

Where in Matthew do you find what you claim?

Ted

2022-12-29 00:11:55 UTC

On Wed, 28 Dec 2022 10:31:00 -0800, Dr.

Post by Dr. Who
(in

On Wed, 28 Dec 2022 06:50:56 -0800 (PST),

On Tuesday, December 27, 2022 at 4:26:41 PM UTC-6,

P+Barker

On Tue, 27 Dec 2022 16:03:37 -0500,

Bethlehem is in the Palestinian West Bank, which has

been

under

Israeli occupation since 1967. It is encircled by a wall

erected

Israel in 2002. All entrances and exits are

controlled

armed

Israeli soldiers. Israeli forces regularly invade the

area,

beating

and abducting residents. Israeli forces sometimes kill

them,

including

prominent Palestinian-American journalist Shireen

Abu-Akleh,

from a

Christian family from Bethlehem. Due to the

influence

of the

Israel

lobby, U.S. taxpayers give Israel over $10 million per

day.

The

churches shown at the end of the video are the

Church

of the

Nativity

1:53

mins.

Bethlehem is controlled by the Palestinians.

Bullshit is just part of Young's nature.

LOL. As it was for Matthew and Luke. They made asses of

themselves

(and contradicted each other) with their idiotic

contortions

have

Jesus born there.

You must not have read those books
yourself, there is NO contradictions.

I'm quite familiar with them, Robert, and there are multiple
contradictions. Shall I list them one at a time?

In lists of ten would be fine. Thanks

I doubt there are ten.
Okay, first one: where did Mary and Joseph live before Jesus was
born? Matthew says Bethlehem, Luke says Nazareth.

Where in Matthew do you find what you claim?

Matthew 2:11. Whose house do you suppose Matthew is referring to?

Then they fled to Egypt until the angel told Joseph he could return
because Herod was dead. Return where?

But oops, the angel forgot to mention Archelaus was in Judea and so
he decided instead to relocate to Galilee.

(To fulfill another nonexistent prophecy.)

Ready for the second contradiction?

Dr. Who

2022-12-29 00:40:08 UTC

On Wed, 28 Dec 2022 10:31:00 -0800, Dr.

Post by Dr. Who
(in

On Wed, 28 Dec 2022 06:50:56 -0800 (PST),

On Tuesday, December 27, 2022 at 4:26:41 PM UTC-6,

P+Barker

On Tue, 27 Dec 2022 16:03:37 -0500,

Bethlehem is in the Palestinian West Bank, which has

been

under

Israeli occupation since 1967. It is encircled by a

wall

erected

Israel in 2002. All entrances and exits are

controlled

armed

Israeli soldiers. Israeli forces regularly invade

the

area,

beating

and abducting residents. Israeli forces sometimes

kill

them,

including

prominent Palestinian-American journalist Shireen

Abu-Akleh,

from a

Christian family from Bethlehem. Due to the

influence

of the

Israel

lobby, U.S. taxpayers give Israel over $10 million

per

day.

The

churches shown at the end of the video are the

Church

of the

Nativity

1:53

mins.

Bethlehem is controlled by the Palestinians.

Bullshit is just part of Young's nature.

LOL. As it was for Matthew and Luke. They made asses of

themselves

(and contradicted each other) with their idiotic

contortions

have

Jesus born there.

You must not have read those books
yourself, there is NO contradictions.

I'm quite familiar with them, Robert, and there are multiple
contradictions. Shall I list them one at a time?

In lists of ten would be fine. Thanks

I doubt there are ten.
Okay, first one: where did Mary and Joseph live before Jesus was
born? Matthew says Bethlehem, Luke says Nazareth.

Where in Matthew do you find what you claim?

Matthew 2:11. Whose house do you suppose Matthew is referring to?
Then they fled to Egypt until the angel told Joseph he could return
because Herod was dead. Return where?
But oops, the angel forgot to mention Archelaus was in Judea and so
he decided instead to relocate to Galilee.
(To fulfill another nonexistent prophecy.)
Ready for the second contradiction?

I am happy to disappoint you, as Matt 2:11 was near two years later, after
the birth of Jesus in Bethlehem. So there was no conflict in scripture.

I have answered that question several times over the years. And it was from
that place they left to go to Egypt since the ruler sent out and order to
kill all male children under the age of two.

Yes, I am ready and if you post your scriptures it will shorten my time
needed to find what isn't there. ;)

Ted

2022-12-29 01:09:38 UTC

On Wed, 28 Dec 2022 11:47:27 -0800, Dr.

Post by Dr. Who
(in

On Wed, 28 Dec 2022 10:31:00 -0800, Dr.

Post by Dr. Who
(in

On Wed, 28 Dec 2022 06:50:56 -0800 (PST),

On Tuesday, December 27, 2022 at 4:26:41 PM UTC-6,

P+Barker

On Tue, 27 Dec 2022 16:03:37 -0500,

Bethlehem is in the Palestinian West Bank,

which has

been

under

Israeli occupation since 1967. It is encircled by a

wall

erected

Israel in 2002. All entrances and exits are

controlled

armed

Israeli soldiers. Israeli forces regularly

invade

the

area,

beating

and abducting residents. Israeli forces

sometimes

kill

them,

including

prominent Palestinian-American journalist

Shireen

Abu-Akleh,

from a

Christian family from Bethlehem. Due to the

influence

of the

Israel

lobby, U.S. taxpayers give Israel over $10

million

per

day.

The

churches shown at the end of the video are the

Church

of the

Nativity

1:53

mins.

Bethlehem is controlled by the Palestinians.

Bullshit is just part of Young's nature.

LOL. As it was for Matthew and Luke. They made asses of

themselves

(and contradicted each other) with their idiotic

contortions

have

Jesus born there.

You must not have read those books
yourself, there is NO contradictions.

I'm quite familiar with them, Robert, and there are

multiple

contradictions. Shall I list them one at a time?

In lists of ten would be fine. Thanks

I doubt there are ten.
Okay, first one: where did Mary and Joseph live before Jesus was
born? Matthew says Bethlehem, Luke says Nazareth.

Where in Matthew do you find what you claim?

Matthew 2:11. Whose house do you suppose Matthew is referring to?
Then they fled to Egypt until the angel told Joseph he could

return

because Herod was dead. Return where?
But oops, the angel forgot to mention Archelaus was in Judea and so
he decided instead to relocate to Galilee.
(To fulfill another nonexistent prophecy.)
Ready for the second contradiction?

I am happy to disappoint you, as Matt 2:11 was near two years

later, after

Post by Dr. Who
the birth of Jesus in Bethlehem. So there was no conflict in

scripture.

Post by Dr. Who
I have answered that question several times over the years. And it was from
that place they left to go to Egypt since the ruler sent out and order to
kill all male children under the age of two.
Yes, I am ready and if you post your scriptures it will shorten my time
needed to find what isn't there. ;)

Okay, I can do that. Interesting that you've answered it previously.
So manger first, then house two years later? Joseph decided to buy a
house in Bethlehem after Jesus was born?

But Matthew doesn't say Joseph returned to Nazareth. He introduces
Nazareth in 2:23. He makes no mention of it prior to then.

Still, your explanation is plausible, I'll admit. Luke makes no
mention of the gold, frankincense, and myrrh. Nor of the star. But
that was because those things happened two years later.

Ted

2022-12-29 01:21:09 UTC

On Wed, 28 Dec 2022 15:26:56 -0800, Dr.

On Wed, 28 Dec 2022 11:47:27 -0800, Dr.

Post by Dr. Who
(in

On Wed, 28 Dec 2022 10:31:00 -0800, Dr.

Post by Dr. Who
(in

On Wed, 28 Dec 2022 06:50:56 -0800 (PST),

On Tuesday, December 27, 2022 at 4:26:41 PM UTC-6,

P+Barker

On Tue, 27 Dec 2022 16:03:37 -0500,

Bethlehem is in the Palestinian West Bank,

which has

been

under

Israeli occupation since 1967. It is

encircled

by a

wall

erected

Israel in 2002. All entrances and exits are

controlled

armed

Israeli soldiers. Israeli forces regularly

invade

the

area,

beating

and abducting residents. Israeli forces

sometimes

kill

them,

including

prominent Palestinian-American journalist

Shireen

Abu-Akleh,

from a

Christian family from Bethlehem. Due to the

influence

of the

Israel

lobby, U.S. taxpayers give Israel over $10

million

per

day.

The

churches shown at the end of the video are the

Church

of the

Nativity

and Christmas Lutheran Church in Bethlehem.

1:53

mins.

Bethlehem is controlled by the Palestinians.

Bullshit is just part of Young's nature.

LOL. As it was for Matthew and Luke. They made

asses

themselves

(and contradicted each other) with their idiotic

contortions

have

Jesus born there.

You must not have read those books
yourself, there is NO contradictions.

I'm quite familiar with them, Robert, and there are

multiple

contradictions. Shall I list them one at a time?

In lists of ten would be fine. Thanks

I doubt there are ten.
Okay, first one: where did Mary and Joseph live before

Jesus

was

born? Matthew says Bethlehem, Luke says Nazareth.

Where in Matthew do you find what you claim?

Matthew 2:11. Whose house do you suppose Matthew is referring to?
Then they fled to Egypt until the angel told Joseph he could

return

because Herod was dead. Return where?
But oops, the angel forgot to mention Archelaus was in Judea

and

he decided instead to relocate to Galilee.
(To fulfill another nonexistent prophecy.)
Ready for the second contradiction?

I am happy to disappoint you, as Matt 2:11 was near two years

later, after

Post by Dr. Who
the birth of Jesus in Bethlehem. So there was no conflict in

scripture.

Post by Dr. Who
I have answered that question several times over the years. And

was from

Post by Dr. Who
that place they left to go to Egypt since the ruler sent out and

order to

Post by Dr. Who
kill all male children under the age of two.
Yes, I am ready and if you post your scriptures it will shorten

time

Post by Dr. Who
needed to find what isn't there. ;)

Okay, I can do that. Interesting that you've answered it

previously.

So manger first, then house two years later? Joseph decided to buy a
house in Bethlehem after Jesus was born?
But Matthew doesn't say Joseph returned to Nazareth. He introduces
Nazareth in 2:23. He makes no mention of it prior to then.
Still, your explanation is plausible, I'll admit.

But this shoots it down. Luke 2:39

And when they had performed all things according to the law of the
Lord, they returned into Galilee, to their own city Nazareth.

Dr. Who

2022-12-29 02:06:42 UTC

On Wed, 28 Dec 2022 15:26:56 -0800, Dr.

On Wed, 28 Dec 2022 11:47:27 -0800, Dr.

Post by Dr. Who
(in

On Wed, 28 Dec 2022 10:31:00 -0800, Dr.

Post by Dr. Who
(in

On Wed, 28 Dec 2022 06:50:56 -0800 (PST),

On Tuesday, December 27, 2022 at 4:26:41 PM UTC-6,

P+Barker

On Tue, 27 Dec 2022 16:03:37 -0500,

Bethlehem is in the Palestinian West Bank,

which has

been

under

Israeli occupation since 1967. It is

encircled

by a

wall

erected

Israel in 2002. All entrances and exits are

controlled

armed

Israeli soldiers. Israeli forces regularly

invade

the

area,

beating

and abducting residents. Israeli forces

sometimes

kill

them,

including

prominent Palestinian-American journalist

Shireen

Abu-Akleh,

from a

Christian family from Bethlehem. Due to the

influence

of the

Israel

lobby, U.S. taxpayers give Israel over $10

million

per

day.

The

churches shown at the end of the video are the

Church

of the

Nativity

and Christmas Lutheran Church in Bethlehem.

1:53

mins.

Bethlehem is controlled by the Palestinians.

Bullshit is just part of Young's nature.

LOL. As it was for Matthew and Luke. They made

asses

themselves

(and contradicted each other) with their idiotic

contortions

have

Jesus born there.

You must not have read those books
yourself, there is NO contradictions.

I'm quite familiar with them, Robert, and there are

multiple

contradictions. Shall I list them one at a time?

In lists of ten would be fine. Thanks

I doubt there are ten.
Okay, first one: where did Mary and Joseph live before

Jesus

was

born? Matthew says Bethlehem, Luke says Nazareth.

Where in Matthew do you find what you claim?

Matthew 2:11. Whose house do you suppose Matthew is referring

to?

Then they fled to Egypt until the angel told Joseph he could

return

because Herod was dead. Return where?
But oops, the angel forgot to mention Archelaus was in Judea

and

he decided instead to relocate to Galilee.
(To fulfill another nonexistent prophecy.)
Ready for the second contradiction?

I am happy to disappoint you, as Matt 2:11 was near two years

later, after

Post by Dr. Who
the birth of Jesus in Bethlehem. So there was no conflict in

scripture.

Post by Dr. Who
I have answered that question several times over the years. And

was from

Post by Dr. Who
that place they left to go to Egypt since the ruler sent out and

order to

Post by Dr. Who
kill all male children under the age of two.
Yes, I am ready and if you post your scriptures it will shorten

time

Post by Dr. Who
needed to find what isn't there. ;)

Okay, I can do that. Interesting that you've answered it

previously.

So manger first, then house two years later? Joseph decided to buy

house in Bethlehem after Jesus was born?
But Matthew doesn't say Joseph returned to Nazareth. He introduces
Nazareth in 2:23. He makes no mention of it prior to then.
Still, your explanation is plausible, I'll admit.

But this shoots it down. Luke 2:39
And when they had performed all things according to the law of the
Lord, they returned into Galilee, to their own city Nazareth.

"They returned to their own city Nazareth." He had to leave it in order to
return.

Ted

2022-12-29 08:04:05 UTC

On Wed, 28 Dec 2022 16:40:08 -0800, Dr.

On Wed, 28 Dec 2022 15:26:56 -0800, Dr.

Post by Dr. Who
(in

On Wed, 28 Dec 2022 11:47:27 -0800, Dr.

Post by Dr. Who
(in

On Wed, 28 Dec 2022 10:31:00 -0800, Dr.

Post by Dr. Who
(in

On Wed, 28 Dec 2022 06:50:56 -0800 (PST),

On Tuesday, December 27, 2022 at 4:26:41 PM UTC-6,

P+Barker

On Tue, 27 Dec 2022 16:03:37 -0500,

Bethlehem is in the Palestinian West Bank,

which has

been

under

Israeli occupation since 1967. It is

encircled

by a

wall

erected

Israel in 2002. All entrances and exits are

controlled

armed

Israeli soldiers. Israeli forces regularly

invade

the

area,

beating

and abducting residents. Israeli forces

sometimes

kill

them,

including

prominent Palestinian-American journalist

Shireen

Abu-Akleh,

from a

Christian family from Bethlehem. Due to the

influence

of the

Israel

lobby, U.S. taxpayers give Israel over $10

million

per

day.

The

churches shown at the end of the video are the

Church

of the

Nativity

and Christmas Lutheran Church in

Bethlehem.

1:53

mins.

Bethlehem is controlled by the Palestinians.

Bullshit is just part of Young's nature.

LOL. As it was for Matthew and Luke. They made

asses

themselves

(and contradicted each other) with their idiotic

contortions

have

Jesus born there.

You must not have read those books
yourself, there is NO contradictions.

I'm quite familiar with them, Robert, and there are

multiple

contradictions. Shall I list them one at a time?

In lists of ten would be fine. Thanks

I doubt there are ten.
Okay, first one: where did Mary and Joseph live before

Jesus

was

born? Matthew says Bethlehem, Luke says Nazareth.

Where in Matthew do you find what you claim?

Matthew 2:11. Whose house do you suppose Matthew is

referring

to?

Then they fled to Egypt until the angel told Joseph he could

return

because Herod was dead. Return where?
But oops, the angel forgot to mention Archelaus was in Judea

and

he decided instead to relocate to Galilee.
(To fulfill another nonexistent prophecy.)
Ready for the second contradiction?

I am happy to disappoint you, as Matt 2:11 was near two years

later, after

Post by Dr. Who
the birth of Jesus in Bethlehem. So there was no conflict in

scripture.

Post by Dr. Who
I have answered that question several times over the years. And

was from

Post by Dr. Who
that place they left to go to Egypt since the ruler sent out and

order to

Post by Dr. Who
kill all male children under the age of two.
Yes, I am ready and if you post your scriptures it will

shorten

time

Post by Dr. Who
needed to find what isn't there. ;)

Okay, I can do that. Interesting that you've answered it

previously.

So manger first, then house two years later? Joseph decided to buy

house in Bethlehem after Jesus was born?
But Matthew doesn't say Joseph returned to Nazareth. He

introduces

Nazareth in 2:23. He makes no mention of it prior to then.
Still, your explanation is plausible, I'll admit.

But this shoots it down. Luke 2:39
And when they had performed all things according to the law of the
Lord, they returned into Galilee, to their own city Nazareth.

"They returned to their own city Nazareth." He had to leave it in order to
return.

Yes, of course. Luke has Joseph go to Bethlehem for the (ludicrously
fictional) census while Mary was pregnant. Jesus is born there and so
they stay to perform all duties "according to the law of the Lord"
and then they return to Nazareth. He doesn't decide to buy a house in
Bethlehem and stay there for two years.

Dr. Who

2022-12-29 15:27:15 UTC

On Wed, 28 Dec 2022 16:40:08 -0800, Dr.

On Wed, 28 Dec 2022 15:26:56 -0800, Dr.

Post by Dr. Who
(in

On Wed, 28 Dec 2022 11:47:27 -0800, Dr.

Post by Dr. Who
(in

On Wed, 28 Dec 2022 10:31:00 -0800, Dr.

Post by Dr. Who
(in

On Wed, 28 Dec 2022 06:50:56 -0800 (PST),

On Tuesday, December 27, 2022 at 4:26:41 PM

UTC-6,

P+Barker

On Tue, 27 Dec 2022 16:03:37 -0500,

Bethlehem is in the Palestinian West Bank,

which has

been

under

Israeli occupation since 1967. It is

encircled

by a

wall

erected

Israel in 2002. All entrances and exits

are

controlled

armed

Israeli soldiers. Israeli forces regularly

invade

the

area,

beating

and abducting residents. Israeli forces

sometimes

kill

them,

including

prominent Palestinian-American journalist

Shireen

Abu-Akleh,

from a

Christian family from Bethlehem. Due to

the

influence

of the

Israel

lobby, U.S. taxpayers give Israel over $10

million

per

day.

The

churches shown at the end of the video

are the

Church

of the

Nativity

and Christmas Lutheran Church in

Bethlehem.

1:53

mins.

Bethlehem is controlled by the Palestinians.

Bullshit is just part of Young's nature.

LOL. As it was for Matthew and Luke. They made

asses

themselves

(and contradicted each other) with their idiotic

contortions

have

Jesus born there.

You must not have read those books
yourself, there is NO contradictions.

I'm quite familiar with them, Robert, and there are

multiple

contradictions. Shall I list them one at a time?

In lists of ten would be fine. Thanks

I doubt there are ten.
Okay, first one: where did Mary and Joseph live before

Jesus

was

born? Matthew says Bethlehem, Luke says Nazareth.

Where in Matthew do you find what you claim?

Matthew 2:11. Whose house do you suppose Matthew is

referring

to?

Then they fled to Egypt until the angel told Joseph he could

return

because Herod was dead. Return where?
But oops, the angel forgot to mention Archelaus was in Judea

and

he decided instead to relocate to Galilee.
(To fulfill another nonexistent prophecy.)
Ready for the second contradiction?

I am happy to disappoint you, as Matt 2:11 was near two years

later, after

Post by Dr. Who
the birth of Jesus in Bethlehem. So there was no conflict in

scripture.

Post by Dr. Who
I have answered that question several times over the years.

And

was from

Post by Dr. Who
that place they left to go to Egypt since the ruler sent out

and

order to

Post by Dr. Who
kill all male children under the age of two.
Yes, I am ready and if you post your scriptures it will

shorten

time

Post by Dr. Who
needed to find what isn't there. ;)

Okay, I can do that. Interesting that you've answered it

previously.

So manger first, then house two years later? Joseph decided to

buy

house in Bethlehem after Jesus was born?
But Matthew doesn't say Joseph returned to Nazareth. He

introduces

Nazareth in 2:23. He makes no mention of it prior to then.
Still, your explanation is plausible, I'll admit.

But this shoots it down. Luke 2:39
And when they had performed all things according to the law of the
Lord, they returned into Galilee, to their own city Nazareth.

"They returned to their own city Nazareth." He had to leave it in

order to

Post by Dr. Who
return.

The census reality is a matter of Roman records. So is the killing of all
male babies under the age of two. IIRC the order also caused one of his boys
under the age of two to be killed, or perhaps relatives close to him. Herod
was well known for that decision, and it was not unusual to have rulers kill
off their relatives so they could not usurp the throne.

If you read those scriptures again you will see that it was because the wise
men where looking for baby Jesus, and they had followed the star to see where
the Baby was, Herod found out and because he was reputed to be a king when he
grew up Herod was all the more interested in the story and after interviewing
them, asked that when they found him to let him know where he was. When he
realized he had been bamboozled by the wise men because they left the area,
under the orders of an angel, the counted back to see what the approximate
time was when they were there and so to ensure he killed the future king he
commanded all males under the age of two to be killed.

Yes, the story must be pieced together but it is all there, and in history
also, in a limited fashion. And Yes, Jesus will rule as king, but for the
last 1K years of life on this planet. His return is not far off, he will
first come in the clouds to pull out all the true believers in him, both dead
and alive. Then a sudden immense calamity occurs and there will be seven
years from that date to the date when he comes to rule the earth. In the
interim over 3/5ths of the earths population will be killed via wars, famines
and natural calamities of immense proportions, but there will be none of the
church people to bug you. Just a couple Jewish prophets and their followers
for the 1st 3.5 years.

Dr. Who

2022-12-29 01:58:30 UTC

On Wed, 28 Dec 2022 11:47:27 -0800, Dr.

Post by Dr. Who
(in

On Wed, 28 Dec 2022 10:31:00 -0800, Dr.

Post by Dr. Who
(in

On Wed, 28 Dec 2022 06:50:56 -0800 (PST),

On Tuesday, December 27, 2022 at 4:26:41 PM UTC-6,

P+Barker

On Tue, 27 Dec 2022 16:03:37 -0500,

Bethlehem is in the Palestinian West Bank,

which has

been

under

Israeli occupation since 1967. It is encircled

by a

wall

erected

Israel in 2002. All entrances and exits are

controlled

armed

Israeli soldiers. Israeli forces regularly

invade

the

area,

beating

and abducting residents. Israeli forces

sometimes

kill

them,

including

prominent Palestinian-American journalist

Shireen

Abu-Akleh,

from a

Christian family from Bethlehem. Due to the

influence

of the

Israel

lobby, U.S. taxpayers give Israel over $10

million

per

day.

The

churches shown at the end of the video are the

Church

of the

Nativity

and Christmas Lutheran Church in Bethlehem.

1:53

mins.

Bethlehem is controlled by the Palestinians.

Bullshit is just part of Young's nature.

LOL. As it was for Matthew and Luke. They made asses

themselves

(and contradicted each other) with their idiotic

contortions

have

Jesus born there.

You must not have read those books
yourself, there is NO contradictions.

I'm quite familiar with them, Robert, and there are

multiple

contradictions. Shall I list them one at a time?

In lists of ten would be fine. Thanks

I doubt there are ten.
Okay, first one: where did Mary and Joseph live before Jesus

was

born? Matthew says Bethlehem, Luke says Nazareth.

Where in Matthew do you find what you claim?

Matthew 2:11. Whose house do you suppose Matthew is referring to?
Then they fled to Egypt until the angel told Joseph he could

return

because Herod was dead. Return where?
But oops, the angel forgot to mention Archelaus was in Judea and